TD Bank Case Study

From Alert Fatigue to Trust: Redesigning TD Bank's U.S. Digital Banking Alert System

PROJECT: TD Bank U.S. Account Alerts Redesign

ROLE: UX Director & Product Design Leader  

TIMELINE: 9 months to first majo release

IMPACT: 60% increase in alert adoption, 45% fraud reduction

TD Bank Case Study

My Role

  • Led a design team of UX Designers, UI Designers, and a UX Copywriter to redesign the alert experience
  • Collaborated with Product Owners and Cross-Functional teams to define user requirements and technical constraints
  • Defined and executed long-term UX strategy for U.S. digital banking alerts for Business and Personal Account holders
  • Directed design sprints and workshops to co-create user-friendly solutions to enable customers to mitigate fraud risks
  • Led the production of high-fidelity wireframes and interactive prototypes using Figma

The Challenge & Our Approach

The Challenge We Faced:

  • Customers were experiencing alert fatigue - many had disabled notifications entirely, leaving them vulnerable to fraud
  • Existing alert system generated too many irrelevant notifications, causing users to ignore critical security warnings
  • Complex setup process prevented customers from configuring alerts that matched their actual needs

Project Objectives:

  • Improve real-time communication and user control
  • Empower proactive financial behavior
  • Strengthen security and fraud prevention

Our Solution Approach:

Redesign the alert system to enhance customer awareness, prevent fraud, and support financial planning by notifying users of key account events, like low balances or unusual activity. Enable users to lock cards, report issues, or transfer funds promptly.

TD Bank alerts system overview

Overview of TD Bank's redesigned alert system architecture and user experience

Key Features & Solutions

Checking & Savings Account Alerts (Threshold Alerts)

Alerts when balances go below or above user-defined thresholds. For example, an alert triggers if a balance falls below $100. Customizable via online or mobile banking.

Design Rationale: We designed flexible threshold options so users could either set simple alerts once or customize them based on their banking habits, like getting notified when their weekly $500 deposit arrives, reducing unnecessary logins and customer service calls.
Alert setup mobile interface

ACH Credit alert configuration showing threshold and notification options

Alert management dashboard

Simplified alert management interface with toggle controls

Fraud Alerts (Credit / Access Cards)

Instant SMS alerts for suspicious card activity. Recipients can reply "Y" to confirm legitimate transactions or "N" to block the card immediately. Seamless fraud control within the messaging channel.

Design Rationale: We expanded the SMS response system to accept multiple reply formats (Y/Yes, N/No) so users could respond naturally, with "Yes" allowing transactions to proceed and "No" flagging them as fraud and escalating to specialists.
Fraud alert mobile interface

Mobile fraud alert interface with quick response options

Instant SMS alerts for suspicious card activity. Recipients can reply "Y" to confirm legitimate transactions or "N" to block the card immediately. Seamless fraud control within the messaging channel.

Design Rationale: We expanded the SMS response system to accept multiple reply formats (Y/Yes, N/No) so users could respond naturally, with "Yes" allowing transactions to proceed and "No" flagging them as fraud and escalating to specialists.

Alert Management & Customer Control

Alerts are fully customizable (type, threshold, delivery method). Tools allow locking cards temporarily, reporting theft, initiating transfers, or reacting to suspected fraud quickly.

Design Rationale: We simplified the alert management interface by grouping related controls together and providing clear on/off toggles, making it easier for users to customize their experience without navigating through multiple screens.

Commercial / Treasury Alerts (eTreasury Platform)

Business users can set up over 20 alert types: balance changes, wires, ACH activity, template status, user entitlement changes, payment status, security alerts, and more.

Design Rationale: We organized the 20+ alert types into logical business operation categories (Cash Management, Transaction Processing, Security & Access) rather than technical system groupings, making it easier for business users to find and configure alerts based on their operational needs.
Business alert management interface

Commercial/Treasury alert dashboard showing organized business alert categories and management controls

Implementation Considerations

  • Integration across platforms: Alerts are accessible via the mobile app and EasyWeb online banking
  • User experience: Needs intuitive settings, clear instructions, and seamless opt-in/out processes
  • Scalability & reliability: Must handle high-volume real-time notifications without delays or overload
  • Data security: Alerts must be delivered securely without exposing sensitive data in transit
Implementation considerations interface

Mobile implementation showing cross-platform alert management and user control options

Challenges & How We Solved Them

Alert Fatigue

Challenge: Over-notification may desensitize users. Balancing frequency and relevance is key.

Solution: Implemented smart defaults and user-defined thresholds to reduce irrelevant notifications.

False Positives

Challenge: Ensure alert systems are accurate—false alarms can erode trust.

Solution: Refined fraud detection parameters and provided clear context in alert messages.

Configuration Accuracy

Challenge: Users must set thresholds appropriately to avoid missing or triggering too many alerts.

Solution: Added suggested threshold amounts based on account history and spending patterns.

Regulatory Vigilance

Challenge: Particularly after recent compliance shortcomings, robust monitoring and alert systems are critical.

Solution: Worked with compliance team to ensure mandatory alerts met regulatory requirements while preserving user choice for optional notifications.

Results & Impact

Key Outcomes & Metrics

  • 60% increase in users enabling alerts (from 23% to 83% of active users within 6 months)
  • 45% reduction in fraud-related losses within 6 months of launch
  • 30% reduction in customer service calls related to alert issues
  • 89% task completion rate for alert configuration (up from 34%)
  • 2024 FICO Decisions Award for Achievements in Fraud Management

Business Impact

The redesigned alert system transformed TD Bank's customer communication strategy, significantly improving both security outcomes and user satisfaction. The project established new design patterns that were adopted across other digital banking products.

Project Summary

Feature Description Design Impact
Threshold Alerts Smart balance notifications with flexible thresholds Reduced customer service calls by 30%
Fraud Alerts SMS verification with expanded response options (Y/Yes, N/No) Improved fraud response rate to 45%
Alert Customization Simplified categorization and toggle controls Increased setup completion from 34% to 89%
eTreasury Alerts 20+ business alerts organized by operational categories Streamlined business user configuration
Overall Project Complete alert system redesign 60% increase in adoption, 45% fraud reduction
Built on Unicorn Platform